• Hibby
    link
    fedilink
    21 year ago

    Older hardware and software that are made by companies who have hostile or ignorant stances towards FOSS are major contributors to at least some of the issues you mentioned. I can tell you that there is active development around solving some GPU/Wayland issues, but the limitations on what Linux can or can’t do isn’t fully the fault of Linux.

    There is definitely room for improvement in Linux. The improvements in just the last three years shows that it has improved at a pretty brisk pace. Free and open community driven operating systems work toward the active needs of the community, so hopefully any issues or bugs you had got reported and you’ve actively checked up on them. I am making an assumption here, but if all of these issues you have had were extremely common, there would be every incentive for development of solutions to them.

    There is some level of compromise that is needed when using proprietary software or hardware from hostile vendors or using some older hardware with Linux. This also goes for company supplied or required hardware/software. Linux might not be for everyone on every piece of hardware right now. The tradeoffs for having control over your hardware and software can sometimes be frustrating.

    As for “blaming the users”, I don’t think I did that at all. I just feel like some folks prefer appliances over heavy machinery. That’s personal preference. Sure, Linux should make onboarding as easy as possible, but in my opinion, the active pursuit of being #1 or #2 in desktop OS use is going down the wrong path. There is a certain type of person who chooses to go down the desktop Linux path and catering to their needs seems much more important for the long-term health of the OS.

    • Square Singer
      link
      fedilink
      11 year ago

      I honestly don’t see how Ubuntu installing the wrong driver is Nvidia’s fault. Ubuntu has both the current and the legacy driver in their repos. When installing the OS it asks you whether you want to install proprietary drivers, which I agreed to, so it installed the non-legacy driver that does not work with the old GPU.

      Also, when installing the correct driver on apt, there is no text prompt or CLI wizard (like in many other tools installed over apt) to actually load that driver into the kernel. I don’t see how this is Nvidia’s fault, as they haven’t created the Ubuntu package.

      That’s squarely on the Ubuntu guys. That has literally nothing to do with hostile vendors.

      • Hibby
        link
        fedilink
        21 year ago

        I can’t speak for Ubuntu or your situation as I don’t have your issues and I don’t use Ubuntu, but I would advise you reach out to the Ubuntu community with your issues and if you can’t find a solution, file a bug report. They are a large community with a lot of engagement, so I would think that you might have luck either solving your problem or pointing their devs toward fixing the issue on their end. The squeaky wheel gets the grease.

        • Square Singer
          link
          fedilink
          1
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          Tbh, I spent enough time fixing it. I don’t want to file bug reports and battle them though a bug log in my spare time. I do enough of that in my work time.

          In my spare time I tend to use a computer to accomplish a task, not to fix the computer.

          And that’s where you hit the “average user” thing again. If an average user encounters a bug, they either live with the bug or give up. If you ask any of your non-dev friends how many of these has ever filed a bug report, I’d venture to say it’s not going to be many.

          And in the few cases where you actually see non-techy people filing a bug report, it’s usually going to be on the level of “HELP! My PC is not working!” and the response will be “Closed for not following the template”.

          • Hibby
            link
            fedilink
            21 year ago

            I don’t know what to tell you. If you want to blame Ubuntu for your issues, but you aren’t willing to go through the standard process of troubleshooting or filing a big report, maybe Linux isn’t for you.

            • Square Singer
              link
              fedilink
              0
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              Dude, I am a dev, I am using Linux for over a decade. I spent hours fixing these issues. But we are talking about “The year of the Linux desktop” and Linux being used by people who aren’t hardcore tech nerds or devs.

              To quote from my edit that you probably didn’t read yet:

              And that’s where you hit the “average user” thing again. If an average user encounters a bug, they either live with the bug or give up. If you ask any of your non-dev friends how many of these has ever filed a bug report, I’d venture to say it’s not going to be many.

              And in the few cases where you actually see non-techy people filing a bug report, it’s usually going to be on the level of “HELP! My PC is not working!” and the response will be “Closed for not following the template”.

              The point I was trying to make is “Linux currently totally is not for everyone. There are a lot of issues that stop regular users from using Linux.” and I was downvoted for that, and people kept argueing whose fault it is. And now you are coming to the conclusion that I was making in the beginning:

              Maybe Linux isn’t for everyone.

              Because it currently totally isn’t.

              What really annoys me with this discussion (and I’ve had the exact same discussions hundreds of times) is that it always goes through the same cycle:

              • A: “Linux is great, everyone should use Linux right now, the only reason not everyone is using Linux is because they are too dumb to switch.”
              • B: “But Linux has issues that are difficult for regular users, e.g. that you have to use CLI every once in a while.”
              • A: “No, you never have to.”
              • B: lists some specific instances where they had to
              • A: “But you are dumb for even doing that. Linux is not made for XYZ use cases”
              • B: “But XYZ use cases are pretty basic and most users run into random ones of these”
              • A: “If you think there are problems, you are maybe to dumb to use Linux”
              • B: “I fixed these issues, it was just a demonstration of where regular users get stuck”

              Combine that with the really misguided notion that anyone who isn’t a tech crack must be dumb because otherwise they would be a tech crack, and it gets really dumb. People completely forget that there are lots of different topics where even most tech cracks have no clue about (e.g. medicine). I have ~20 years of experience as a dev. I know my way around the things I’m working with. I am the one everyone calls if they have issues with their computers. But I got no clue about fixing cars, medicine, or making clothes, just to name a few. And I am really grateful that if I go to my doctor, he treats me and doesn’t tell me I’m dumb because I don’t have a medical degree.

              • Hibby
                link
                fedilink
                11 year ago

                Okay buddy. You obviously didn’t come here to do anything but grind your axe. 3% of desktop use is pretty cool, even if it’s likely just a ton of Steam Decks. Anyway, have a nice time developing.

                • Square Singer
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -1
                  edit-2
                  1 year ago

                  Well, fanboy, have fun pushing people out of Linux. People like you are a major part of the reason that it’s still only 3%.

                  Just imagine that: There’s a free OS that doesn’t track you, doesn’t serve you ads, you don’t need the newest hardware to run it, it does almost anything that Windows does, and yet, it’s got only 3 meagre percent of market share after 30 years.

                  You think that is because it’s so easy to get into if you don’t have a tech background?

                  Sadly, next to the technical hurdles and the bad UX, there is a really toxic community that is happy to shit on anyone who dares to say that Linux isn’t perfect.